In what many see as yet another blow to accountability, a federal judge on Monday dismissed a lawsuit against former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo regarding his handling of nursing home deaths during the COVID-19 pandemic. The lawsuit, filed by families of those who lost loved ones in nursing homes, accused Cuomo and his administration of undercounting fatalities and concealing the true scope of the disaster that unfolded under his leadership.
For millions of Americans, particularly those who lost family members in New York’s nursing homes, this dismissal feels like yet another example of political elites evading justice. Cuomo, once heralded as a pandemic hero, saw his reputation crumble as the truth about nursing home deaths began to emerge. His administration was found to have grossly underreported the number of fatalities in nursing homes and assisted living facilities, and a controversial directive issued by his office early in the pandemic allowed COVID-positive patients to be sent back into nursing homes, potentially accelerating the spread of the virus.
Despite these facts, Cuomo’s spokesman Rich Azzopardi framed the judge’s dismissal as a victory. In a statement to Fox News, Azzopardi said, “During the last four years, the debate over COVID in nursing homes has been weaponized, distorted, and contorted beyond recognition by those using this situation for their own politics. However, anytime this gets taken out of the political arena, the truth wins.” He went on to claim that the dismissal was a triumph of justice, just as similar investigations by the DOJ and the Manhattan district attorney had previously cleared Cuomo.
But is this truly a case of “justice prevailing,” or is it yet another example of the political class protecting its own? Cuomo resigned from office in August 2021, not because of the nursing home scandal, but amid sexual harassment allegations. His fall from grace was swift, but many believe that he still has not fully been held accountable for the decisions that may have cost thousands of lives during the pandemic.
The Nursing Home Deaths Scandal: What Happened?
The heart of the controversy surrounding Cuomo’s handling of the pandemic lies in a directive his administration issued in March 2020. At a time when the virus was ravaging the elderly, the Cuomo administration ordered nursing homes to accept COVID-positive patients from hospitals. Over 9,000 recovering COVID-19 patients were sent back to nursing homes, where many believe they may have spread the virus to other vulnerable residents.
The number of COVID-19 deaths in New York’s long-term care facilities was initially reported at around 6,000. However, it was later revealed that the actual death toll was closer to 15,000—more than twice the reported number. Critics argue that Cuomo’s administration deliberately underreported the number of nursing home deaths to shield the governor from political fallout.
Republican lawmakers, particularly those on the congressional subcommittee investigating the matter, have been relentless in their pursuit of answers. Earlier this year, Cuomo was grilled by Republicans in a hearing where he was forced to defend his administration’s actions. They zeroed in on the March 2020 directive, which was rescinded only after it became clear that it was contributing to outbreaks in nursing homes. Cuomo, however, shifted blame to the Trump administration, accusing them of failing to provide sufficient testing and personal protective equipment in the early days of the pandemic.
“This is all a diversion to blame New York and other states for the culpability of the federal response, which was malpractice,” Cuomo said, deflecting responsibility away from his own decisions.
A report from the House committee on the matter did not specifically address whether the patients discharged from hospitals were still contagious when they were sent back to nursing homes. However, many believe that this omission only further muddies the waters, leaving unanswered questions about the true impact of Cuomo’s directive.
The Aftermath: Political Fallout and Accountability
Cuomo’s defense has consistently been that his administration was acting on the best available science at the time, a claim echoed by a separate state report commissioned by his successor, Governor Kathy Hochul. This report, released earlier this year, concluded that while the policies for handling COVID-19 in nursing homes were “rushed and uncoordinated,” they were based on what was believed to be sound scientific advice at the time.
But for the families who lost loved ones, that explanation rings hollow. For them, the dismissal of this lawsuit feels like yet another instance of the political elite avoiding accountability for catastrophic decisions. Their lawsuit, which was dismissed on Monday, was one of the last remaining legal avenues to hold Cuomo accountable for what they believe was gross negligence in handling the most vulnerable members of society during the pandemic.
Listen to “Women Who Willingly Engage in Sexual Depravity” on Spreaker.
Many Republican lawmakers and conservative commentators see the judge’s ruling as a political whitewash, designed to protect Cuomo and his administration from the consequences of their actions. Cuomo’s defenders, including his spokesperson, have continually framed the controversy as a political attack rather than a legitimate inquiry into the truth. The question remains: how much of this is politics, and how much is a genuine search for accountability?
Conclusion: Justice or Politics?
The dismissal of this lawsuit leaves a bitter taste for many Americans who believe that the handling of COVID-19 in New York’s nursing homes was a preventable tragedy. While Cuomo and his team have attempted to frame this as a political issue, the facts remain: over 15,000 long-term care residents lost their lives, and the Cuomo administration initially underreported those numbers.
Cuomo may have avoided legal consequences for now, but the shadow of the nursing home scandal will continue to loom over his legacy. As Republicans continue to push for answers and accountability, it’s clear that the debate over Cuomo’s handling of the pandemic is far from over. The families who lost loved ones deserve more than political spin—they deserve the truth, and they deserve justice.
I want to know what you think!
Send me your views, thoughts or what’s on your mind and we will feature on our newsletter or show!
Email to [email protected] OR
Leave a text, voice note or voicemail for the show on what your thoughts are at 708-982-0974
Connect with me on Spreely Social CLICK HERE to Check out Spreely Social
And don’t forget to watch us LIVE weekdays at 1p est! CLICK HERE to Watch The Rants of Izzo Show!
-Izzo
